MOTHER MARKETING PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: MOTHER🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

The Company recognizes the importance of having a good internal control system in place to help ensure that the business operations, including the performance of various duties, are transparent, reliable, and have a system of checks and balances. The Board of Directors has assigned the Audit Committee to review the Company's internal control and internal audit systems, as well as to review the Company's operations to ensure that they are appropriate and effective. This is to ensure that the Company has a business operating system that is in line with the guidelines of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and the Securities and Exchange Commission.

The Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2025, held on February 24, 2025, was attended by all three audit committee members. The Board of Directors assessed the adequacy of the Company's internal control system in accordance with the assessment form for the adequacy of the internal control system of the Securities and Exchange Commission, under the concept of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (“COSO”) by inquiring information from the management in all 5 areas, namely

1. Control Environment

2. Risk Assessment

3. Control Activities

4. Information and Communication

5. Monitoring Activities

The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the Company has an adequate and appropriate internal control system in place for the nature of its business. The five components of internal control are effective in preventing transactions with major shareholders, directors, executives, or related persons. In addition, the Company has sufficient personnel to operate under the internal control system and monitor and supervise the operations to prevent the Company's assets from being misused or unauthorized by directors or executives, as well as transactions with conflicting and related parties. The Company has also engaged IVL Audit Co., Ltd. (“IVL”) to audit and assess the adequacy of the Company's internal control system by interviewing and inquiring from executives, supervisors, and relevant personnel according to the organizational structure, document inspection, etc. The internal auditor has prepared an internal control audit report and submitted it to the Audit Committee for the Company to take action to correct and improve the quality of the internal control system and to ensure that the Company has a process that can oversee the operations to be in accordance with the objectives, goals, laws, and relevant regulations effectively, can prevent assets from fraud, not be misused by directors or executives, and have accurate and reliable accounting and reporting.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)

1) Entity-level Internal Control Assessment

From the assessment of the design effectiveness of the entity-level internal control (Control Design Effectiveness Analysis), with the scope of assessment referencing the COSO framework and the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand, including the guidelines of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the internal auditors are of the opinion that the Company has established an adequate and appropriate entity-level internal control system.

2) Process-level Internal Control Assessment

From the assessment of the process-level internal control of the business cycle and the systems audited, with the scope of assessment referencing policies, regulations, operating manuals, including best practices of the Institute of Internal Auditors of Thailand and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, the internal auditors are of the opinion that the Company should expedite the improvement of process-level internal controls as observed to be adequate and appropriate, and ensure strict compliance.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)000

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of IVL Co., Ltd., operated by Ms. Waldee Seebunruang and Ms. Angkana Thaicharoensathien. From reviewing the company's information (Company Profile) and the background of Ms. Waldee Seebunruang and Ms. Angkana Thaicharoensathien, the committee is of the opinion that the independent auditor possesses appropriate and sufficient education, experience, and training to perform the duties of the company's internal auditor. Moreover, they have independence in auditing and assessing the adequacy of the internal control system and the company's compliance with the system.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The Audit Committee shall be responsible for reviewing the Company's internal control and internal audit systems to ensure their adequacy and effectiveness. The committee shall also consider the independence of the internal audit function and provide approval for the appointment, transfer, termination of the head of internal audit or other units responsible for internal audit. The committee may recommend the review or audit of any items deemed necessary and important. Additionally, the committee shall submit recommendations for improvements to the internal control system to the Board of Directors, in consultation with the external auditor and the internal audit manager.

Related Party Transactions

Introduction

Necessity and reasonableness of related party transactions

The Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2568 held on February 24, 2568, considered the information on the Company's related party transactions for the year ended December 31, 2567, and the Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2568 held on February 24, 2568, considered the information on the Company's related party transactions for the year 2567 ended December 31, 2567, together with inquiries from the Company's management and a review of the information disclosed in the notes to the financial statements by the Company's auditors. The Audit Committee is of the view that the Company's related party transactions for the year ended December 31, 2567, are divided into 2 groups, as follows:

1. Ordinary business transactions include the sale of goods, the purchase of goods for resale, etc., which are transactions that the Company conducts in the ordinary course of business. These transactions are necessary, reasonable, and do not cause any disadvantage to the Company. The selling price of goods determined by the Company is the same as the selling price to outside parties, and the purchase price of goods for resale is comparable to the market price.

2. Other transactions apart from ordinary business transactions and transactions in support of ordinary business, such as credit line guarantees, which the Audit Committee has considered and is of the opinion that such related party transactions are necessary, reasonable, and do not cause any disadvantage to the Company.

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
TJK Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonRice trading business

• Ms.Juraiwan is a director of TJK and a major shareholder in TJK, holding 25 percent of the registered capital of 2.00 million baht.

• In 2024, TJK did not rely on the Company as its revenue from the Company was less than 30 percent.

2024-12-31T00:00
Krabi DC Company LimitedJuristic PersonBusiness Type: Tobacco and Cigarette Distributor

• Mr.Varat Chokchaiwithas is a shareholder of Krabi DC Co., Ltd., holding 30 percent of the registered capital of 2 million baht.

2024-12-31T00:00
Mr.Ekkapong ChokchaiwitutPerson

• Is a director of the Company, Managing Director, and authorized director of the Company.

• Is a major shareholder of the Company, holding 36.64 percent of the total issued and paid-up shares, totaling 286 million shares (after the sale of ordinary shares to retail investors).

2025-02-24T00:00
Mr.Treepaphat ChokchaivithadPerson

• Is a director of the company and an authorized director of the company.

2025-02-24T00:00
Mrs.Yarinut ChokchaivithadPerson

• Is the wife of Mr.Treepaphat Chokchaivithad

• Is a shareholder of the company, holding 0.42 percent of the total number of 286 million issued and paid-up shares (after the issuance of ordinary shares to retail investors).

2025-02-24T00:00
Mother Bakery Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonBusiness Type: Bakery production and sales

Mrs.Yarinut Chokchaivithad is a director and shareholder, holding 100 percent of the registered capital of 1 million baht.

2024-12-31T00:00
Ms.Juraiwan Sae TieoPerson

• Is a director of the company, the Deputy Managing Director, and an authorized director of the company.

• Is the second largest shareholder of the company, holding 27.97 percent of the total number of issued and paid-up shares, totaling 286 million shares (the number of shares after the issuance of ordinary shares to retail investors).

2025-02-24T00:00
Atom 2019 Company LimitedJuristic PersonRestaurant/Food Service Business

•Mr.Varat Chokchaiwithas is a director and shareholder of ATOM, holding 3.720 percent of the registered capital of 4.957 million baht.

2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
1.34 · Necessity: The company purchases packaged rice from TJK for distribution in its branches. All rice sales from TJK to customers are conducted through the Bplus system, similar to general product sales. The company has a 30-day payment term, consistent with the payment terms offered to other suppliers. The gross profit margin for rice purchases from TJK is the same as that for purchases from other distributors. Additionally, the purchase price of rice from TJK is comparable to that of other suppliers. · Description: Purchase of packaged rice from TJK Co., Ltd. for distribution · As of yesteryear: 2.21 · Nature of transaction: The company purchases packaged rice from TJK Co., Ltd. · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are considered ordinary business transactions conducted at arm's length. The purchase price of the rice aligns with prevailing market prices, and the gross profit margin is consistent with purchases from other suppliers. Furthermore, the terms of trade adhere to standard business practices, mirroring those applied to transactions with unrelated parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.47 · 0.18 · Necessity: The company sells consumer products to TJK based on the needs of TJK's customers. When TJK's customers want to purchase products that TJK does not have in stock, TJK will place an order with the company. The company then delivers the products directly to TJK's customers along with TJK's own products. All sales transactions with TJK are conducted through the Bplus system, similar to sales to regular customers, with a payment term of 30 days. · Description: Selling diapers, UHT milk, plastic bags, drinking water · As of yesteryear: 0.4 · Nature of transaction: The company sells consumer products to TJK Co., Ltd. · Audit committee opinion: The transactions listed are regular trading activities and are considered reasonable. The selling price is based on the price list and follows normal trading terms, similar to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.45
0.48 · Necessity: The company purchases ISCORE and PLAYOFF brand cigarettes from Krabi DC Co., Ltd. for distribution in its retail stores. DC is the sole distributor of these cigarette brands in Krabi province. The purchase price from DC is comparable to other distributors. All cigarette sales from DC to customers are conducted through the BPlus system, similar to general product sales. The company has a payment term of 7 days. · Description: Purchase of stationery from stationery company D.C. Limited for distribution · As of yesteryear: 0.66 · Nature of transaction: The company purchased ISCORE and PLAY OFF brands from Karabi D.C. Co., Ltd. · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are considered normal business transactions and are deemed reasonable due to the fact that Krabi DC Co., Ltd. is the sole authorized distributor of the said cigarette brands in Krabi Province. The purchase prices are in line with prevailing market prices and adhere to standard commercial terms, equivalent to transactions conducted with unrelated parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.19
0.36 · Necessity: The company leased a building in the city from Mr.Ekkapong to open a branch. It was a 3-year lease agreement, starting from April 2025, with a monthly rent of 30,000 baht, the same rate Mr.Ekkapong received from the building owner. The rental fee was not appraised because it was not deemed cost-effective. Therefore, the company used a benchmarking approach, comparing it to rental rates of similar buildings in the same area. · Description: Rental fee for building lease from Mr.Ekkapong Chokchaiwitut (M1 City Branch) · As of yesteryear: 0.36 · Nature of transaction: The company leased a building from Mr.Ekkapong Chokchaiwitut to open a new branch. · Audit committee opinion: The list details the rental agreements for spaces used as the company's branches within the city. The listed agreements are deemed reasonable, and the rental rates are comparable to prevailing market rates in the area. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.36
0.05 · Necessity: The company sold musical instruments to Mr.Treepaphat Chokchaivithad with a 30-day payment term. All sales transactions to Mr.Treepaphat were conducted through the Bplus system, consistent with sales to general customers. · Description: Selling beverages such as liquor and soft drinks · As of yesteryear: 0.47 · Nature of transaction: The company sells musical instruments to Mr.Treepaphat Chokchaivithad · Audit committee opinion: The transactions listed are regular trading transactions. They are considered reasonable and justifiable. The selling prices are in accordance with the price list. The terms of sale are consistent with normal business practices, equivalent to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 2.02
0.58 · Necessity: The company accepts bakery products from Mrs.Yarinut for consignment sale at its branch stores, with a payment term of 15 days. Mrs.Yarinut 's bakery sales are conducted through the Bplus system for all transactions, similar to sales of consigned goods from other suppliers. The gross profit margin for consigned goods from Mrs.Yarinut is the same as that for similar consigned goods from other suppliers. · Description: Purchase of consigned goods from Mrs.Yarinut Chokchaivithad at for distribution · As of yesteryear: 1.01 · Nature of transaction: Bakery consignment sales revenue from Mrs.Yarinut Chokchaivithad · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are considered normal trade practices, conducted at reasonable and justifiable prices. The purchase prices reflect prevailing market rates, and the gross profit margins align with those applied to similar consigned goods from other distributors. Furthermore, the terms of trade adhere to standard industry practices, mirroring those extended to unrelated third parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 1.22
0.01 · Necessity: The company purchases bakery supplies upon request from hotel customers from Mother Bakery. This is because the company does not keep these items in stock for sale, and hotel customers prefer to order through the company to receive trade credit. · Description: Purchased bakery supplies from Mather Bakery Co., Ltd. for distribution. · As of yesteryear: 0.01 · Nature of transaction: The company purchases bakery ingredients for distribution to hotel clients as per their orders. · Audit committee opinion: The transactions listed are regular transactions conducted at arm's length. The prices and terms are in line with general market practices, as if transacting with unrelated parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0 · 1.43 · Necessity: The company sells wheat flour for baking to Mother Bakery with a 7-day payment term. All sales transactions to Mother Bakery are conducted through the Bplus system, similar to sales to other customers. · Description: Selling baking ingredients (milk, coffee, flour, oil, coconut milk, sugar, etc.) · As of yesteryear: 0.0 · Nature of transaction: The company sells wheat flour for baking to Mather Bakery Company Limited. · Audit committee opinion: The transactions listed are regular trading transactions. They are considered reasonable and justifiable. The selling prices are based on the price list, and the sales terms are in accordance with standard business practices, equivalent to transactions with external parties. · As of year before yesteryear: 0.0
219.67 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantee pertains to credit facilities secured from financial institutions to support the company's business operations, in accordance with the terms and conditions stipulated by these institutions. This guarantee is provided without any remuneration. The company has formally submitted a written request to the financial institutions for the release of personal guarantees, aiming to relieve Mr. Aekapong and Ms. Juraiwarn from their guarantee obligations following the company's listing on the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The first financial institution has acknowledged this request verbally and intends to proceed with the release upon the company's successful listing. However, should the financial institutions choose not to discharge Mr. Aekapong and Ms. Juraiwarn from their guarantee obligations in the future, both individuals will remain as guarantors for the company's credit facilities without receiving any compensation. · Description: Credit Line: - Overdraft - Promissory Note - Long-Term Loan · As of yesteryear: 219.67 · Nature of transaction: Company's Mortgages and Charges (Land Title Deed with Structures) · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transactions are considered beneficial to the company's business operations as they provide working capital and enhance liquidity. The loans from the financial institutions are secured by two guarantors, Mr. Aekpong Chokchaiwitas and Ms. Juraiwon Sae-Tiew, as required by the conditions for obtaining financial support. Therefore, entering into these transactions is reasonable and in the best interest of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 219.67
5.94 · Necessity: The aforementioned guarantee pertains to a car hire purchase loan with a financial institution, adhering to the specific hire purchase loan requirements of that institution. It is important to note that this guarantee does not involve any fees or compensation. · Description: Auto Loan Limit · As of yesteryear: 4.57 · Nature of transaction: Lease Agreement Guarantee with Financial Institutions · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned transaction, a car lease for business operations, is deemed beneficial to the company. The lease agreement, which includes guarantees from Mr. Aekpong Chokchaiwitsat and Ms. Juraiwon Sae-Tiaw, is necessary to comply with the financial institution's terms and conditions. Therefore, this transaction is reasonable and serves the best interests of the company. · As of year before yesteryear: 4.57

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2024 held on February 29, 2024, resolved to establish a policy and procedures for transactions between the Company and persons with potential conflicts of interest or connected persons to ensure that the transactions are transparent and in the best interests of the Company. The Company will comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, including regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, as well as comply with the requirements for disclosure of connected transactions and other relevant criteria. Interested parties will not be able to participate in the approval of such transactions. In the event that such connected transactions are required by law to be approved by the Board of Directors' meeting, the Company will arrange for the Audit Committee to attend the meeting to consider and provide opinions on the necessity and reasonableness of such transactions. In conducting ordinary course of business transactions or transactions in support of ordinary course of business that are on terms and conditions generally commercially available, and transactions that are on terms and conditions not generally commercially available, the following principles shall be adhered to:

Transactions with terms and conditions generally commercially available

The Board of Directors has resolved in principle to allow the management to approve related party transactions with terms and conditions generally commercially available between the Company and its directors, executives, or connected persons. This is applicable if such transactions have the same commercial terms as those that a prudent person would enter into with an unrelated party under the same circumstances, with bargaining power free from the influence of their status as a director, executive, or connected person. The Company shall prepare a report summarizing such transactions for reporting at each quarterly meeting of the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors.

Transactions with terms and conditions not generally commercially available

Transactions with terms and conditions not generally commercially available must be reviewed and commented on by the Audit Committee before being submitted to the Board of Directors and/or the shareholders' meeting (as the case may be) for further approval. The Company shall comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the requirements for disclosure of connected transactions and other relevant criteria. In the event that the Audit Committee does not have expertise in considering potential connected transactions, the Company will arrange for a qualified person, such as an independent auditor or property valuer, to provide an opinion on such connected transactions for the Audit Committee and/or the Board of Directors and/or shareholders (as the case may be) to use as information in making decisions to ensure that such transactions are necessary and reasonable, taking into account the best interests of the Company. The Company will disclose connected transactions in the annual registration statement and notes to the financial statements audited by the Company's auditor.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

In the event of any related party transactions in the future, the Board of Directors must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, as well as the rules, announcements, orders, or regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Capital Market Supervisory Board, and the Stock Exchange of Thailand, as well as compliance with the regulations on the disclosure of related party transactions of the Company or its subsidiaries in accordance with accounting standards prescribed by the Federation of Accounting Professions and the Certified Public Accountants of Thailand, and other relevant regulations.

The Audit Committee Meeting No. 1/2567 on February 29, 2567 and the Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2567 on February 29, 2567 acknowledged and approved in principle the Company's transactions with related parties that will occur continuously in the future, including:

1. Purchase of rice products from TJK Co., Ltd. for resale at each branch of the Company. This transaction has been reviewed and approved in principle by the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors.

2. Sale of goods to TJK Co., Ltd. according to the purchase orders of TJK Co., Ltd.'s customers.

3. Purchase of cigarettes from Krabi DC Co., Ltd. for resale.

4. Purchase of bakery ingredients from Mother Bakery Co., Ltd. for resale to customers in the hotel business group.

5. Purchase of bakery ingredients from Mr.Treepaphat for resale to customers in the hotel business group.

6. Sale of goods to Mr.Treepaphat according to his purchase order.

7. Lease of a building from Mr.Ekkapong to open as M1 branch (city branch).

8. Receiving bakery products on consignment from Mrs.Yarinut for resale at the branch.

9. The major shareholders of the Company (Mr.Ekkapong and Ms.Juraiwan) are loan guarantors to financial institutions for the Company.

In addition, the Board of Directors Meeting No. 1/2567 on February 29, 2567 resolved to establish a policy for the Company's lending of money, prohibiting the Company from lending money to directors, executives, and persons or juristic persons related to the Company, for transparency in management, which will result in a good image for the Company and gain confidence from shareholders.

The Audit Committee will review and provide opinions on related party transactions that are ordinary course of business or support the ordinary course of business on a quarterly basis. However, for transactions that are not in the ordinary course of business that may occur in the future, the Company will have the Audit Committee review the necessity and reasonableness of entering into such transactions prior to entering into them. For all related party transactions, the Company will disclose such transactions in the Annual Information Form (Form 56-1) and the Company's Annual Report (Form 56-2) in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act and the rules, regulations, announcements, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand.

Contents